Flu Leads Rikers to Cancel Inmate Visits
Published: May 16, 2009
The Department of Correction said Saturday that inmates at Rikers Island
were advised to tell friends and relatives not to visit this weekend
after it was disclosed late Friday that a prisoner received a diagnosis
of probable swine flu there earlier in the week.
A prison spokesman said the
inmate, who had been sent to Rikers on April 18, was admitted to the
Elmhurst Hospital Center on Wednesday after complaining of flulike
symptoms.
“I’m told he is not in serious condition,” the spokesman, Stephen J. Morello, said Friday night.
The
disclosure came in the aftermath of six public school closings in
Queens and Brooklyn on Friday because of the spread of the virus,
formally known as the A(H1N1) strain.
Asked on Saturday if there are any more swine flue cases within the city corrections system, Mr. Morello said, "No."
He added that there were no new plans for treating and housing inmates with the flu.
"If more cases come forward, we may need to take similar actions in
other housing areas,” Mr. Morello said, “but as of now the protocols
and the policies that we have put in place are what we are going with."
He said officials have told inmates — fewer than 70 — in the two
affected housing areas that, "they should call anybody who they think
will come and visit and tell them not to come and visit this weekend.
Those inmates will not have visits this weekend."
Mr. Morello
said the Correction Department and the Department of Health and Mental
Hygiene had developed a prevention protocol for swine flu. It includes
screening every new inmate for symptoms and checking prisoners who seek
medical attention for swine flu, no matter why they asked to be
examined.
He said all of the areas in which the inmate with the
probable case swine flu, whom he declined to identify, had been held
had been sanitized. “All the other inmates in the area in which he was
held, including those closest to him, have been examined,” Mr. Morello
said, noting that no one else showed signs of the flu.
Mr.
Morello said no inmates would be moved in or out of the two areas where
the ill inmate had been housed, the Anna M. Kross Center, but that it
would continue its usual operation.
The union representing guards
at Rikers demanded that the Kross Center be closed. “This is a deadly
disease which has proven to spread quickly and can inflict immediate
harm to anyone who comes in contact with someone who shows symptoms,”
said Norman Seabrook, the president of the union, the Correction
Officers’ Benevolent Association.
He said the infected inmate had
been in the general population. “The hallways just going back and
forth, there are dozens of inmates in the hallways,” Mr. Seabrook said.
“That facility needs to be sanitized just like a school.”
He said he would tell correction officers who have worked at the Kross Center to schedule physicals with their doctors.
But Mayor Michael Bloomberg and his departing health commissioner, Dr. Thomas R. Frieden, acknowledged Friday the city’s schools seem to have become both a sentinel and an incubator for the new H1N1 strain of flu.
“It
appears at this point in schools in New York City in these days to be
spreading more rapidly than traditional influenza,” Dr. Frieden said.
“We don’t know why that is, but the fact we have neither a vaccine nor
experience being infected with this strain of influenza are likely
explanations.”
Some parents, school staff and teachers’ union
officials wondered whether the city was moving too slowly to close
schools with high absenteeism.
Nancy Crespo’s daughter, Alexis,
a seventh grader, attends Intermediate School 238 in Queens, which was
closed Thursday. She said that nearly 80 children were quarantined
Tuesday in the auditorium, and that her daughter had a 102-degree fever that night. She called the school’s main office Wednesday but was brushed off, she said.
“I wish it would have been easier for me to get answers,” Ms. Crespo said.
Mitchell
Wiener, an assistant principal at the school, was still in critical
condition Saturday and breathing on a ventilator at Flushing Hospital
Medical Center.
“Nothing has gotten worse,” his son, Adam Wiener,
said in a telephone interview on Saturday. “They are treating him very
aggressively and we have reason to hope.”
On Friday, officials
said Mr. Wiener, 55, may have had health problems that made him more
vulnerable to the flu. Adam Wiener said that his father had had gout, but had it under control through medication.
Mr.
Wiener’s wife, Bonnie, lashed out at the city Friday for failing to act
earlier to close the school. “I know we have a duty to educate the
children of New York,” said Ms. Wiener, who is a reading teacher at the
same school and is not sick. But, she added, “something just doesn’t
fit right.”
Mr. Bloomberg and Dr. Frieden defended their caution
by saying that they were trying to balance the health of students with
the child-care and educational needs of families.
“Day by day we’re learning more,” Dr. Frieden said. “It’s a judgment call.”
Mr. Bloomberg added: “We close schools as infrequently as we can. Our kids need more time in school, not less.”
Late
Friday, the city announced it was closing Junior High School 74 in
Bayside, Queens, where 26 students had flulike symptoms; Public School
107 in Flushing, Queens, where 49 students had symptoms; and
Intermediate School 318 in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, where 53 students
had symptoms. The schools will not reopen until the day after Memorial Day, according to employees at the schools.
Randi Weingarten,
president of the teachers’ union, said her staff had received reports
of high numbers of absent students at 21 schools on Friday.
She said more schools could close over the weekend, as officials analyze the reported illnesses.
With the new school closings — at least four closed for a few days earlier this month — the anxiety
that had seemed to dissipate across the city began returning. Occupancy
at the pediatric emergency room of Elmhurst Hospital Center, for
example, was up 35 percent, with parents bringing their children in at
the slightest sign of illness, though no swine flu had been confirmed
there, said Dario Centorcelli, a hospital spokesman.
The virus
may be spreading rapidly through schools because children are just not
very good at personal hygiene, said Dr. Nathan Litman, director of pediatrics and pediatric infectious diseases at the Children’s Hospital at Montefiore Medical Center in the Bronx.
But
he said that in a normal flu season, 30 to 40 percent of children and
young adults from the ages of 5 to 15 or 20 typically are infected with
flu. “So this may merely be an exaggeration of that background
experience that we’ve had.”
So far, only five cases of swine flu
have been confirmed among the six newly closed schools, including four
students and the assistant principal. But the small number of confirmed
cases — 178 citywide — is partly because the city is not trying to be
comprehensive in its testing, officials said, but rather to monitor the
virus’s spread.
Ms. Weingarten of the teachers’ union supported
the city’s handling of the school closings. “You’re pitted against
these concerns — not disrupting the school year, not panicking parents
and educators and kids — versus what to do if you have a cluster of
cases,” she said.
Reporting was
contributed by James Barron, David W. Chen, Anemona Hartocollis, Javier
C. Hernandez, Mick Meenan, Kenny Porpora, Liz Robbins and Rebecca White