BBC NEWS | UK | Bird flu preparations criticised
Last Updated: Wednesday, 22 February 2006, 02:24 GMT
Bird flu preparations criticised
Poultry farmers have been told they may have to move their
birds inside
The government is wrong not to have supplies of the bird flu vaccine
to use on poultry flocks in the event of an outbreak, a campaign
group has said.
Soil Association director Patrick Holden accused the government of
"a dereliction of duty" after it emerged it had no stocks and none
on order.
Ministers said this week the government does not favour vaccination
as a method of dealing with bird flu.
But Mr Holden said every available method must be used to fight the
virus.
When the first case of a wild bird infected with the highly virulent
H5NI strain of bird flu was discovered in France at the weekend, the
debate among British farmers about the merits of vaccination
intensified.
'Too limited'
Government officials have argued vaccination was costly and labour
intensive.
They believe the current available vaccines are too limited and that
vaccinated birds are still able to carry the disease.
QUICK GUIDE
Bird flu
And it was decided that culling would be the most effective way of
controlling the disease.
Mr Holden, who is director of the organic farmers' organisation,
said that while he appreciates the complexities involved in
vaccination, it was not excusable for the government to effectively
ignore it.
He said there were farmers with free range and organic flocks who
would welcome it as part of an overall eradication strategy.
The Conservative environment spokesman Peter Ainsworth said he was
surprised at the government's decision.
The H5N1 virus, which causes bird flu, does not pose a large-scale
threat to humans, as it cannot pass easily from one person to
another.
Experts, however, fear the virus could mutate to gain this ability,
and in its new form trigger a flu pandemic, potentially putting
millions of human lives at risk.
Poultry farmers have been told to prepare to move their birds inside
in case avian flu hits the UK.
While it was not inevitable the virus would arrive, the risk had
increased, Tony Blair's spokesman said on Monday.
There are an estimated 200 million birds on farms across the UK and
between 10% and 15% are free range.
Current British policy is that birds would be ordered inside only if
the disease was found in the UK.
EU officials are to hold a second day of talks in Brussels on
Wednesday on whether to allow the vaccination of poultry to fight
the spread of bird flu.
France and the Netherlands want to start vaccination programmes, but
Germany and other members are opposed.
22 new cases of bird flu on German island Feb 21 2006
icWales
Tests have confirmed another 22 cases of bird flu on the northern
German island of Ruegen.
The report from the Friedrich-Loeffler institute brings the total
number of cases of the deadly H5N1 virus found in wild birds in
Germany to 103, primarily on Ruegen.
A cull of poultry has been ordered in the area, and troops have been
deployed to help clear away dead birds.
So far, no domestic birds or humans have been diagnosed with the
virus in Germany.
icWales - Bird flu reaches France
Bird flu reaches France Feb 19 2006
icWales
The deadly H521 strain of bird flu moved a step closer to the UK
after France confirmed its first case,
The French Agriculture Ministry said the virus was detected in a
dead wild duck found in the town of Joyeux, near Lyon, last weekend.
It is the closest case to the UK so far of the lethal strain, which
is responsible for the deaths of 91 people in Asia and Turkey.
The announcement in France comes as the disease spreads throughout
Europe.
In Austria, authorities are ordering all poultry to be kept indoors
following strong indications that a wild swan found dead in the
capital Vienna would test positive for H5N1.
Story continues
ADVERTISEMENT
Germany announced another 28 wild birds had been found to have the
deadly strain of bird flu, with hundreds more being tested.
Greece, Italy and Slovenia have also notified outbreaks, and results
are awaited on samples from Austria and Hungary sent to the EU's
testing laboratory in Weybridge, Surrey.
Outside Europe, India announced its first cases of H5N1 in chickens
after 30,000 birds died in the past two weeks in Navapur,
Maharashtra and some tested positive for the disease.
The British Government has admitted it is likely bird flu would
spread to the UK.
While humans have so far only contracted the disease directly from
birds, scientists fear H5N1 could mutate into a form easily passed
between humans and spark a human flu pandemic.
Animal Health Minister Ben Bradshaw tried to reassure the public
that the discovery of the disease in wild birds would not damage the
poultry industry, or see a repeat of the Foot and Mouth disease
disaster.
He said: "Most of our big poultry organisations and businesses are
very careful about disease spreading. They have very strict rules
about who comes on and off and they have, I think, very good
contingency plans.
"Most of the international organisations think that we do have a
good contingency plan, but vigilance and quick reaction is the most
important thing in the case of any outbreak.
"It's very different from Foot and Mouth. Avian flu is not nearly as
virulent, it doesn't spread on the air like Foot and Mouth, it's
only spread through contact with bird faeces and our poultry
industry is not as concentrated as parts of the dairy industry in
parts of the North West and South West.
"So the likelihood of it spreading in that way is not as high as it
was for Foot and Mouth," he told BBC News 24.
The Government has drawn up plans to set up one-mile exclusion zones
if a wild bird is found to be infected with the deadly strain.
Inside the zone, all poultry movements would be halted, and if any
poultry was found to be infected the entire flock would face being
culled.
In France, where 200,000 farms raise 900 million birds a year, all
poultry has been ordered inside or vaccinated in a bid to prevent
the spread from wild birds to fowl.